/

How to Document MSP Security Readiness for Cyber Insurance Applications

by Stela Panesa, Technical Writer
How to Document MSP Security Readiness for Cyber Insurance Applications blog banner image
How to Document MSP Security Readiness for Cyber Insurance Applications blog banner image

Try our #1 rated endpoint management platform on G2

NinjaOne dashboard screenshot

Automate the Hardest Parts of IT

Key Points

  • Document MFA, endpoint protection (EDR), backups, patching and vulnerability management, incident response, access control, and email security and training.
  • Prove MFA enforcement by pairing a Microsoft Entra ID MFA registration export with Conditional Access policy exports.
  • Test backups regularly and keep immutable or offline copies, encryption settings, and dated restore logs as proof.
  • Map controls to NIST CSF 2.0, CIS Controls v8.1, or ISO/IEC 27001:2022 and summarize the results in a compliance scorecard.
  • Automate evidence collection with scheduled scripts and store versioned, dated files in one cyber insurance readiness folder.
  • Refresh your evidence every quarter and before each application or renewal and confirm current carrier requirements with your broker.

Cyber insurers want current, dated proof that your controls work. For most applications, that means evidence of enforced multi-factor authentication (MFA), endpoint protection coverage, tested and protected backups, patching and vulnerability management, a written incident response plan, and managed access.

Cybersecurity Ventures projected that cybercrime would cost the world $10.5 trillion in 2025 and expects the annual figure to reach about $12.2 trillion by 2031 or roughly $1 trillion per month. As a result, more companies are looking for higher insurance coverage, and insurers are asking for more detailed documentation.

This guide covers two situations. In the first, you apply for your own MSP cyber and technology errors and omissions coverage. In the second, you help clients assemble evidence for their policies. The evidence is similar, but insurers may ask MSPs extra questions about remote management tools, privileged access, and tenant separation, so confirm the details with your broker.

Automate software updates and demonstrate timely vulnerability remediation for insurance audits.

Start your NinjaOne free trial

What do cyber insurers ask MSPs to document?

Most cyber insurance applications ask for evidence in the seven areas below:

ControlWhat to showEvidence examples
Multi-factor authenticationMFA required for email, remote access, cloud apps, and privileged accountsConditional Access policy export, MFA registration report, privileged account list
Endpoint protectionEDR on every endpoint and serverCoverage report with device counts and percentages
BackupsEncrypted, immutable, or offline copies with tested restoresBackup configuration export, dated restore test log
Patching and vulnerability managementPatch timelines met and findings tracked to closurePatch compliance report, vulnerability summary
Incident responseWritten plan that’s reviewed and testedPlan with version history, tabletop exercise notes
Access controlPrivileged access limited and reviewedAccess review logs, inactive account reports
Email security and trainingEmail authentication and completed trainingSPF, DKIM, and DMARC settings, training completion logs

Security posture reports

These reports demonstrate how well protected your MSP is from common cyberthreats. They should include:

ComponentPurpose/value
Recent vulnerability assessments and patching logsDemonstrates that your systems are regularly scanned for vulnerabilities and patches are applied on time
Endpoint protection coverage report showing the percentage of endpoints and servers with an active EDR agent (plus alert monitoring evidence)Confirms that endpoint protection is active and monitored on every device since many underwriters distinguish EDR from traditional antivirus
Multi-factor authentication (MFA) enforcement and access logs across all privileged accountsEnsures that MFA is enforced for all critical accounts

Backup and disaster recovery (BDR) verification

This reassures insurers that your organization can recover from data loss or system failure.

ComponentPurpose/value
Documented backup schedules, retention policies, and encryption standardsShows that your backups are regular, secure, and compliant with industry data protection standards
Logs of successful restore tests and failover drillsHighlights that your backup strategies have been tested and are working in practice

Tip: Keep a dated log of restore tests and store it with your backup configuration exports. NinjaOne Device Backup boot verification captures a screenshot as evidence that a Windows image backup can boot.

Policy frameworks and governance

These documents establish that your organization implements a structured approach to cybersecurity.

ComponentPurpose/value
Incident response plan and evidence of testingProves readiness in case of a breach
Acceptable use, breach notification, and data retention policiesEnsures that your employees know and understand their responsibilities
A map of controls to NIST CSF 2.0 (including the Govern function), CIS Controls v8.1, or ISO/IEC 27001:2022, summarized in a compliance scorecardDemonstrates that your security practices align with industry standards

Access control and privilege management

This section demonstrates that you don’t grant access to systems and data without proper oversight.

ComponentPurpose/value
Logs of inactive or orphaned account reviewsShows that your organization is actively managing user accounts
Privilege escalation policies and audit trailsIllustrates how your organization grants and monitors escalated access
Logs from recent access reviewsEstablishes that you regularly review and update access rights

Automating documentation processes for cybersecurity risk assessment

Since compiling security documentation can be time-consuming, you can use scripting to automate the process. This sample PowerShell script exports the MFA registration status of every user in Microsoft Entra ID (formerly Azure AD). A registration export shows who has enrolled an authentication method. Pair it with an export of your Conditional Access policies or security defaults settings to show that MFA is required for email, remote access, and privileged accounts.

Connect-MgGraph -Scopes “AuditLog.Read.All”

$stamp = Get-Date -Format “yyyy-MM-dd”

$folder = “C:\ComplianceEvidence”

New-Item -ItemType Directory -Path $folder -Force | Out-Null

Get-MgReportAuthenticationMethodUserRegistrationDetail -All |

Select-Object UserPrincipalName, UserDisplayName, IsAdmin,

IsMfaRegistered, IsMfaCapable, IsPasswordlessCapable,

DefaultMfaMethod,

@{ Name = “MethodsRegistered”; Expression = { $_.MethodsRegistered -join “; ” } } |

Export-Csv “$folder\MFA_Registration_$stamp.csv” -NoTypeInformation

Disconnect-MgGraph

Best practices for effective cybersecurity documentation

Here are some additional best documentation practices to make preparing for a cybersecurity readiness assessment easier:

Create a “cyber insurance readiness” folder

Set up a centralized folder where you can put all the key documentation that insurers typically ask for during a security readiness assessment, including:

  • Backup logs
  • Vulnerability scan summaries
  • Policy templates
  • MFA snapshots

Organizing all your files in one place will make filing for new insurance applications easier.

Use version control and timestamping

To ensure that you don’t accidentally submit outdated documentation to insurers, all your files should have:

  • A clear version number (e.g., v1.2, v2.0)
  • A last updated date
  • A change log, if applicable

This will help you maintain a clear audit trail.

Leverage simple compliance mapping

Map your documents and controls to a recognized cybersecurity framework, like:

  • NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF) 2.0
  • CIS Controls v8.1
  • ISO/IEC 27001:2022

A mapping table or checklist demonstrates that your organization’s cybersecurity strategies align with the industry’s best practices.

Train clients on their role

In addition, you must train your clients on their role in maintaining a secure infrastructure:

Documenting these shared responsibilities prevents misunderstandings and helps strengthen your client’s overall security posture.

Review and refresh your documentation quarterly

Cyber insurance requirements can change quickly, so you should review and update your documentation at least every quarter. Set recurring reminders to re-run automation scripts for exporting data and incorporate insurer feedback into your existing documentation.

Coordinate with brokers beforehand

Finally, talk to your insurance brokers before the cybersecurity readiness assessment. Ask them about the documentation they typically request, their preferred formats, and any frameworks they follow.

Eliminate manual audit prep and generate proof of efficient vulnerability remediation.

Watch the NinjaOne Patch Management demo

What is cyber insurance, and why is it important?

Cyber insurance, or cyber liability insurance, helps businesses cover financial losses from data breaches and cyberattacks. It works just like any insurance policy: providers will pay for covered damages and costs, including data recovery, legal fees, and even lost revenue. With the cost of cybercrimes increasing alarmingly, organizations need safeguards to help them recover the financial and reputational damage they may incur from an attack.

However, it’s important to note that cyber insurance can never replace an effective cybersecurity program. Instead, think of it as your safety net and robust security posture as the foundation of your defense mechanism. Without a strong cybersecurity program in place, most insurers will offer you limited protection for a steep price. Worse yet, they’ll refuse to issue you coverage.

How does NinjaOne help you collect evidence?

NinjaOne includes capabilities that help you gather and organize the evidence that insurers ask for.

Evidence neededNinjaOne capabilityWhat it does
Policies and runbooksNinjaOne DocumentationStores policies, checklists, and runbooks inside the NinjaOne platform, where your team already manages endpoints
Encryption statusNinjaOne Endpoint ManagementMonitors BitLocker encryption on Windows and FileVault encryption on macOS from the console
Scheduled evidence collectionNinjaOne AutomationRuns automation scripts on a schedule or through policy conditions
Backup restore evidenceNinjaOne BackupBoot verification tests Windows image backups and captures a screenshot as evidence
Vulnerability and patch evidenceNinjaOne Autonomous Patch Management and Vulnerability ManagementTracks patch status and groups vulnerability data by CVE on system, organization, and device dashboards
Third-party scan dataNinjaOne Vulnerability ImporterIngests vulnerability scan data from supported third-party scanners

A walkthrough of this guide is available on How to Document MSP Security Readiness for Cyber Insurance Applications.

Quick-Start Guide

NinjaOne’s Security Documentation Capabilities

1. Vulnerability Management

NinjaOne offers a Vulnerability Importer that allows MSPs to:

  • Import vulnerability data from multiple scanning tools
  • Centralize vulnerability tracking across devices
  • Generate comprehensive vulnerability reports

2. Security Frameworks and Tracking

Track cybersecurity Key Performance Indicators (KPIs):

  • Framework coverage
  • Risk reduction speed
  • Evidence readiness
  • Align with cybersecurity frameworks like NIST

3. Key Documentation Tools

  • Centralized visibility
  • Compliance tracking
  • Automated reporting
  • Device health status monitoring

Recommended Approach for Cyber Insurance Documentation

1. Comprehensive Vulnerability Tracking

Use NinjaOne’s Vulnerability Importer to document:

  • Identified vulnerabilities
  • Remediation status
  • Patch management efforts

2. Security Incident Response

3. Continuous Monitoring and Reporting

Implement quarterly security reviews

Generate reports showing:

  • Security controls
  • Risk mitigation efforts
  • Continuous improvement

4. Integration of Security Tools

Utilize integrated security solutions like:

Strategic documentation: The key to a successful cybersecurity readiness assessment

As cybercrimes continue to escalate, insurance providers are becoming increasingly selective about the organizations to which they grant coverage. They don’t just want to hear that you have the right security measures in place; they want you to prove it by submitting clear, verifiable evidence.

This is where strategic documentation comes in. Well-organized reports and policies that align with industry standards make it easier for underwriters to evaluate your application and for you to answer their follow-up questions. More importantly, strategic documentation reinforces your MSP’s reputation as a proactive cyber-risk mitigator.

Related topics:

FAQs

Inaccurate answers can lead to a denied claim or a canceled policy, and many carriers also run outside-in scans of internet-facing assets to check what you report.

Review every answer against current evidence before you sign and correct anything that’s changed since your last renewal.

Usually yes. A client’s policy generally protects that client, not your MSP, so most MSPs carry their own cyber and technology errors and omissions coverage.

Ask your broker how the policies interact and what the carrier expects from your remote management and privileged access controls.

The client owns its policy and typically signs its application, so the client is accountable for the answers, while the MSP usually produces the evidence.

Record who owns each control in a shared responsibility matrix and have the client review the evidence before it’s submitted.

Often not. Many underwriters treat traditional antivirus and EDR as separate controls, and they ask which product you run and what percentage of endpoints and servers it covers. Check the application wording and deploy EDR on every device where it asks for it.

Tell your broker before you apply and document the gap with a dated remediation plan and an owner. Prioritize MFA, EDR, and tested backups first since missing any of them can mean no quote at all. Carriers may still offer coverage with conditions, higher premiums, or sublimits.

Ask your broker for the carrier’s preferred formats and then submit dated exports (CSV or PDF) that show the tenant or device scope. Screenshots work as supporting proof, but timestamped exports are easier to verify and to refresh each quarter.

You might also like

Ready to simplify the hardest parts of IT?